The pictures show that the user is Gwin... You'res' is not right...

My theory: Gwin killed Rsnail.They say Rsnail looked EXACTLY like Gwin.How did he get to the Mine?Gwin made his puffle attack Rsnail.he dragged him to the mine,made a hole in the roof,put him by the mine,and left the island so everyone would think it was him.
-notrealname2

I've already written my theory. I'm pretty sure it's correct, Heh, they don't call me Detective YouTube for nothing! Oh wait... no one calls me that...

Theory:
Gwin always said his hat was valuable. It really was. Gwin didn't know that, though. He just said it was valuable to him. As he wore the hat, he looked EXACTLY like Rsnail. A penguin walked up to him, believing he was Rsnail, and asked for an autograph. The penguin then sent a buddy request. What that penguin knew, was that Gwin's hat was worth A LOT of money. Since they were now buddies, the penguin was able to go to Gwin's igloo. The penguin took Gwin's puffle, held him hostage, and put him at the south east end of the Mine Shack. Gwin went out looking for his puffle, and saw him at the Mine Shack. Gwin slipped and fell on a puddle and fell right below the pillars on the wall of the Mine Shack. The penguin came along and buried his face in the snow and choked Gwin to death. He then broke off the pillar to make it look like Gwin committed suicide. The penguin then took the hat and ran off with a boat load of money in his hand.
Another theory is Gwin saw his puffle at the Mine Shack, the penguin choked/poisoned/intoxicated Gwin and buried him in the snow.
Evidence:
1. Gwin said his hat was valuable.
2. He looked just like Rsnail.
3. There were no marks on Gwin, meaning something could have been going through his blood system.
4. Gwin's puffle was found at the south east end of the Mine Shack.
5. Gwin befriended a penguin and gave an autograph.

I Know!



1. Dont they look the same Gwen and Rsnail!
Maybe Rsnail got mad because Gwin copyed him.

2. Maybe the puffle knocked over the wood and Gwen
fell to the ground knocking him out to death?

3. Gwen could of suicided by jumping off the mine and broke
some stuff?

Well that's what i got
See ya!

oooh amazing

Outstanding theories! Good luck!

I'm a real detective. I made, in school for only my friends, Mystery9... I locked Mystery9 because there was no buisness... I had to...
Now, I'm gonna make a place in Vassar, Michigan. We will be detectives...

Awesome! Can't wait to see!!

Damen, I Have Found Some Suspects:

1. Zipline, Because I've Seen A Lot Of People Say He Is The Criminal...
2. Mateo, Because I Saw Him Wearing A Red Viking Helmet.
3. Rsnail, Because He Probably Didn't Like Gwin Wearing His Clothes.
4. Pieguy, Because I Saw Him With A Gun, Saying "EVERYONE PUT YOUR HANDS UP!"

Cool,i cant wait to do alot and earn credits!

Quote:

I'm a real detective. I made, in school for only my friends, Mystery9... I locked Mystery9 because there was no buisness... I had to...

Now, I'm gonna make a place in Vassar, Michigan. We will be detectives...

So did I. P.D.S.A is my school agency.

Quote:

Damen, I Have Found Some Suspects:



1. Zipline, Because I've Seen A Lot Of People Say He Is The Criminal...

2. Mateo, Because I Saw Him Wearing A Red Viking Helmet.

3. Rsnail, Because He Probably Didn't Like Gwin Wearing His Clothes.

4. Pieguy, Because I Saw Him With A Gun, Saying "EVERYONE PUT YOUR HANDS UP!"

Actually I ordered Zipline to put his hands up. I arrested him.

Quote:

Damen, I Have Found Some Suspects:



1. Zipline, Because I've Seen A Lot Of People Say He Is The Criminal...

2. Mateo, Because I Saw Him Wearing A Red Viking Helmet.

3. Rsnail, Because He Probably Didn't Like Gwin Wearing His Clothes.

4. Pieguy, Because I Saw Him With A Gun, Saying "EVERYONE PUT YOUR HANDS UP!"

Actually I ordered Zipline to put his hands up. I arrested him.

Double post glitch. Sorry...